Web Horology Message Board


"BEWARE OF DOG"  |  HOME |  Sitemap |  NAWCC - HTI |  Special Project |  WHMB Index | "BEWARE OF DOG"

Go Back   Web Horology Message Board > The Pocket Watch Industry > Pocket Watch Discussions > Watch Companies

Watch Companies Discussions on watches and watch companies.

Reply
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Unread 10-01-2014, 04:32 PM
Jon Jon is offline
Administrator
 
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Boston, Massachusetts
Posts: 18,187
Talking NAWCC refuses to allow educational links-shame on the assoc

NAWCC refuses to allow educational links-shame on the nat ass


This one is truly laughable:


A non Howard "expert" NOT writes:

"In my opinion, the movement is a genuine E. Howard Series III, the serial number mostly likely started out as 7316, if you draw an imaginary line under the serial number, the first digit is sloped to a more acute angle to "the line" than the third digit, to me indicating that it could have been a seven at one time.

It's obvious to me, this watch was handled by a master watch maker, it seems he/she was faced with the old a broken jewel repair, didn't have the correct parts and/or means to replace the jewel and decided to take the next best course of action, which was to reach for his/her Black and Decker electric drill so as to obtain a hole big enough to accept a hole jewel he/she had in inventory. Once the initial stage of restoration was completed, he/she carefully sanded down the affected area with I guess a P40 grade of sand paper to conceal the repair, inadvertently, part of the first digit was removed. The silver lining of this master repair, was the creation an experimental Howard. To me, the results speak for them self.

Bravo"

JUST HOW MANY TRUE EXPERTS ARE THERE--NOT MANY.

Well, there are so many things wrong with this Swiss fake that it is a joke!

gilding color

engraving

HS stud shape, style

balance under

apparent large size of cock

lettering/engraving

incorrect patent placement at barrel surround

wrong escutcheon at winding

balance jewel screw position

shape and style of Geneva SW

earlier series III's do not have the raised setting

I did not know Mershon's was spelled "MER SHON'S"

I wonder what the underside of the dial looks like

how about the curvette winding holes?

look at the space between the plate and inner case frame

AND, if in hand, I am certain I could find a many more "faking errors."

This one is ever so easy, actually laughable and typical of watch "expert" pretenders to some horological throne--most of these fellas are just guessing and haven't a clue! (I have a NY and London bridge to sell!) It shows just another reason why the assoc is in trouble--people posting wrong information and the HUGE DROP in mawcc membership!
__________________
Jon "the truth" Hanson
American Horologe Co. (America's Most Respected Name).
Founder of nawcc Chapter 149--the leading pocket watch collectors' club!
Long time collector; NOW over 60 years of collecting, researching, educating and assisting collectors with pocket watch issues.
Join the ranks of ethical/credible pocket watch collecting practices--KEEP POCKET WATCHES ORIGINAL--DON'T PART THEM OUT OR SWITCH COMPONENTS!
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:51 PM.


Copyright 2002-2007, Web Horology, All Rights Reserved